New Faces of 1956 - The Ethel Barrymore Theatre
 


 
Some familiar faces in the photo above are Maggie Smith & Billie Hayes.  Ok, so maybe Ms. Hayes' face is not terribly familiar, since she's well known as Witchiepoo, so she's in the third row from the top, first one on the left.  According to the playbill, Ms. Hayes "Met Paul Lynde, sketch director, while touring the elite boites with a tab revue, "What's New."  He recommended her to Mr. Sillman for "New Faces of '56."  Here's a clip of Ms. Hayes with Paul in his Halloween special.